Administrative ReviewsThe Department of Commerce (DOC) has still not published the preliminary results from the 3rd annual administrative review. As you may recall, the rates published in June were incomplete and contained a major error. The DOC says they will come out with those rates in October, but it is looking like they may not do that, and instead, just publish their final numbers in December.
The fourth administrative review has begun. The DOC is selecting mandatory respondents now. They rejected our request to select ZhongWang (ZW). Their reasoning is that ZW is not the exporter of record in the trade data, so they can’t justify selecting them. Therefore, it is likely we will see some of the same Chinese extruders we’ve seen before.
Scope IssuesWe lost a couple of decisions involving tubular products (handles, poles, etc.). If those parts come in with ‘substantial’ hardware, fasteners, etc. the DOC is excluding them. If it’s a simple pole with no extraneous parts, it is included. There was a scope request made for solar mounting systems. Given the department’s previous ruling on mounting systems, we did not fight this one. That’s a shame, but we have virtually no chance of winning. We did win one against a request for extrusions used in automotive. The DOC characterized them as an incomplete subassembly (metal bushings). We are still awaiting a decision on 5xxx alloy extrusion (slated for early October).
CircumventionThe Fair Claims Act case out of Florida was finalized with the last of the involved parties cutting their deal with the government. Fines/duties of approximately $500,000 were levied against Wingfield Industries. This was the fourth of the four companies that were transshipping product through Malaysia. This case was blown open by a whistleblower that came forward to report the scheme.
The Puerto Rico case is still in the sentencing phase. Now, the ring leader that was sentenced to jail has joined the other defendants in requesting a jury trial. We will need to work hard to follow this case in the event we have a chance to testify. Since our letter writing campaign that caused the judge to issue jail time, the plea deals have been torn up. So now, the case will essentially start over.
The Zhongwang issue has stolen all the headlines recently. Dupre Analytics released a report via the Internet exposing ZW fraud on a number of levels. This report not only validated our concerns, but went even farther. The AEC is reviewing its options to find the best way to respond. It is clear that Dupre’s allegation of transshipment through third countries is deeply concerning. We sent a press release calling for investigations into these allegations.