Skip to main content

Circumvention Has Become Biggest Issue with AEC Fair Trade

Our trade case continues to be extremely active, especially with the big news generated from the Dupre Analytics report.  There are several issues to report that are changing with each week.

Administrative Reviews

The Department of Commerce (DOC) has still not published the preliminary results from the 3rd annual administrative review. As you may recall, the rates published in June were incomplete and contained a major error.  The DOC says they will come out with those rates in October, but it is looking like they may not do that, and instead, just publish their final numbers in December.
The fourth administrative review has begun.  The DOC is selecting mandatory respondents now.  They rejected our request to select ZhongWang (ZW).  Their reasoning is that ZW is not the exporter of record in the trade data, so they can’t justify selecting them.  Therefore, it is likely we will see some of the same Chinese extruders we’ve seen before.

Scope Issues

We lost a couple of decisions involving tubular products (handles, poles, etc.).  If those parts come in with ‘substantial’ hardware, fasteners, etc. the DOC is excluding them.  If it’s a simple pole with no extraneous parts, it is included.  There was a scope request made for solar mounting systems.  Given the department’s previous ruling on mounting systems, we did not fight this one.  That’s a shame, but we have virtually no chance of winning.  We did win one against a request for extrusions used in automotive.  The DOC characterized them as an incomplete subassembly (metal bushings).  We are still awaiting a decision on 5xxx alloy extrusion (slated for early October).

Circumvention

The Fair Claims Act case out of Florida was finalized with the last of the involved parties cutting their deal with the government. Fines/duties of approximately $500,000 were levied against Wingfield Industries.  This was the fourth of the four companies that were transshipping product through Malaysia.  This case was blown open by a whistleblower that came forward to report the scheme.

The Puerto Rico case is still in the sentencing phase.  Now, the ring leader that was sentenced to jail has joined the other defendants in requesting a jury trial.  We will need to work hard to follow this case in the event we have a chance to testify.  Since our letter writing campaign that caused the judge to issue jail time, the plea deals have been torn up.  So now, the case will essentially start over.

The Zhongwang issue has stolen all the headlines recently.  Dupre Analytics released a report via the Internet exposing ZW fraud on a number of levels.  This report not only validated our concerns, but went even farther.  The AEC is reviewing its options to find the best way to respond.  It is clear that Dupre’s allegation of transshipment through third countries is deeply concerning.  We sent a press release calling for investigations into these allegations.

Summary

Overall the case is going well.  Even though the scope issues have settled into something less than what we wanted, the base case is still unchallenged and effective.  Circumvention has become the biggest issue, and with our added work in D.C. we are starting to gain traction in getting help from the government.  Your continued support and time make all of this happen.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Aluminum Extruders Coalition Files Historic Case; Customs Says “Yes”

Well, in case you missed it, a group of Aluminum Extruders Council members filed a historic AD/CVD case against 15 countries.  All 15 countries will be sued for dumping (AD), and four will be sued for subsidies (CVD).  In a press release issued earlier this week, which you can read here , the countries were identified as well as the projected duties the coalition seeks.  Anyone within the four walls of the Aluminum Extruders Council knew this was coming.  It has been discussed for four years.  To address rising imports, we battled in the enforcement arena, we went hard after products under assault in scope challenges and worked hard on the 232.  After exhausting every available option, and never seeing a dent in the import stats, we were faced with this hard decision.  That is where we are today.  The Hearing will be held later this month, and decisions will start to be rendered in the weeks that follow.  Communications about the details of this case will be handled by the Coalition,

A Nice Win to Start the Year!

 For months you’ve read my blog posts bemoaning the terrible decisions coming out of Washington D.C. related to our case.  Well, with the New Year, we have a fresh start.  And it’s a good one!  The industry has won its first Enforce and Protect Act (EAPA) case involving fencing extrusions.  On December 20, 2023, Fortress withdrew its request for an administrative review, prompting U.S. Customs & Border Protection (CBP) to terminate the administrative review entirely. Termination of the review makes the CBP’s affirmative determination of evasion final.  When terminating the review, CBP clarified that termination does not in any way preclude CBP or other agencies from pursuing additional enforcement actions against Fortress or imposing penalties should the need arise. The other EAPA fencing case is pending, and it appears the respondent is not participating.  We submitted voluntary factual information and the company in question did not submit written arguments by the November 6, 202

USITC Issues 332 to Assess Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Where Sustainability Meets Trade Policy

  The U.S. International Trade Commission (USITC) is undertaking a new factfinding investigation that will assess the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions intensity of steel and aluminum produced in the United States.  As part of its investigation, the Commission will conduct a survey by issuing questionnaires to firms with facilities producing steel and aluminum in the United States, whether U.S. or foreign owned, to collect data on their production of these goods and associated GHG emissions. This survey will be mailed to all extruders in the United States.  The announcement made by the ITC on July 6, 2023, can be accessed here.  As requested, the USITC, an independent, nonpartisan federal agency, will prepare a public report.  The report will provide, to the extent practicable: GHG emissions intensity estimates of steel and aluminum produced in the United States by product category and production stage in 2022, with data on Scope 1, 2, and 3 emissions defined as: Scope 1: Direct emissions